Understanding the Role of Public Adjusters & Attorneys in Insurance Claims

When disaster strikes—whether it’s a fire, flood, storm, or other loss—policyholders often find themselves overwhelmed by the process of filing insurance claims. In these moments, two professionals often come into the picture: public adjusters and attorneys. While both can provide valuable assistance, their roles, responsibilities, and areas of expertise differ significantly. Understanding the distinctions can help policyholders make informed decisions about who to engage when navigating complex insurance issues.

Public adjusters are licensed professionals who work on behalf of policyholders to evaluate, document, and negotiate insurance claims. Unlike insurance company adjusters, whose duty is to protect the insurer’s interests, public adjusters exclusively advocate for the policyholder. They are skilled at assessing the extent of property damage, interpreting policy language, and presenting detailed claims that maximize the payout. For many homeowners or business owners, a public adjuster can relieve the burden of combing through policy fine print and calculating losses, ensuring that no detail is overlooked. Their compensation is often a percentage of the final settlement, aligning their success with the client’s recovery, but in some states they are required to charge an hourly rate.

Attorneys, on the other hand, play a different but equally important role. When an insurance claim becomes contentious—such as when coverage is denied, payments are delayed, or disputes over bad faith arise—an attorney steps in to provide legal representation. Attorneys bring the power of litigation, legal strategy, and courtroom advocacy. While public adjusters can negotiate settlements, they cannot practice law or file lawsuits. Attorneys are essential when the dispute crosses into legal territory, requiring enforcement of contractual rights or remedies under state insurance laws. Their involvement is particularly critical when insurers engage in tactics that go beyond ordinary negotiation and veer into unlawful practices.

The distinction between public adjusters and attorneys often lies in the stage and complexity of the claim. For example, a homeowner with significant water damage may hire a public adjuster to prepare a claim that fully accounts for repairs, replacement costs, and additional living expenses. If the insurer accepts the claim and negotiations remain cooperative, the adjuster’s expertise may be enough to secure a fair settlement. However, if the insurer denies coverage outright, argues over policy interpretation, or acts in bad faith, an attorney may be needed to escalate the matter legally. In some situations, the two professionals may even collaborate: the adjuster handling documentation and valuation, while the attorney provides legal direction when disputes arise.

Cost is another factor to consider. Public adjusters in Louisiana charge an hourly fee, making them a practical first step for straightforward claims. Attorneys, while often more expensive, offer legal remedies that adjusters cannot provide. This cost difference highlights the importance of evaluating the nature of the dispute before deciding whom to engage. For many policyholders, starting with a public adjuster makes sense, but having an attorney in reserve is a wise safeguard if negotiations break down.

Ultimately, the choice between a public adjuster and an attorney depends on the circumstances of the claim. Policyholders benefit most when they recognize the complementary nature of these roles. Public adjusters bring technical expertise in damage assessment and claim preparation, ensuring that no stone is left unturned in documenting losses. Attorneys bring the authority of the law, holding insurers accountable when they fail to honor their obligations. Together, these professionals can provide a powerful support system for policyholders navigating one of the most stressful experiences of their lives.

By understanding the distinct and overlapping functions of public adjusters and attorneys, policyholders can better protect themselves during the claims process. Choosing the right professional at the right time not only increases the likelihood of a fair recovery but also reduces the stress of dealing with insurers in the wake of a loss. In the end, knowledge is power—and knowing that you can rely on Averill & Reaney in any situation when insurance challenges arise is one of the most important steps toward achieving a just outcome.

‍